“Mom, Dad, you told me Santa Claus was real. You told me the Easter Bunny was real. You told me the Tooth Fairy was real. Now you say those were all pretend. What about Jesus?”
Not every child will ask that question. But if yours did, would you be prepared to answer? More importantly, have we considered whether the way we present these childhood traditions could make our teaching about Jesus harder to trust?
Most parents are trying to give their children happy memories. They enjoy the excitement, the surprises, and the anticipation. They remember their own childhood and want their children to experience the same delight. I understand that. But good intentions do not remove our responsibility to consider what we are teaching along the way.
Children depend on adults to help them understand what is real. They do not yet have the experience to examine every claim we make. When Mom or Dad says something is true, that assurance carries weight. Their trust is something we should handle carefully.
There is a difference between telling a story and insisting that the story actually happened. Children can enjoy talking animals, imaginary adventures, and characters who could never exist. We do not have to convince them those things are real for them to enjoy the story. Pretending together can be a happy part of childhood when everyone understands that it is pretend.
The concern begins when adults deliberately present something invented as fact, support it with supposed evidence, and continue defending it when a child begins asking honest questions. At that point, we should stop and consider what we are asking the child to believe and why.
We teach our children that telling the truth matters. We correct them when they make up a story to convince us of something that never happened. Yet we may expect them to accept that our own invented stories are different because we intended them to be enjoyable.
Will a child understand that distinction as easily as we do? Or might the child wonder when it is acceptable to mislead someone?
This becomes more serious when the same trusted adults also teach about Jesus. We tell children that He lived, died, and rose again. We teach them to pray to Him, trust Him, and believe His promises. We want them to understand that the gospel is true and that their response to Christ matters.
Then they discover that other things we confidently presented as real were inventions. A child could reasonably ask what makes our teaching about Jesus different.
That does not mean every child who believes in Santa will later reject Christ. Many do not. It would be wrong to claim that one childhood tradition explains why people leave the faith. But we do not need to prove that every child will struggle before asking whether we are creating an unnecessary obstacle to trust.
God gave parents a serious responsibility concerning His Word: “These words, which I am commanding you today, shall be on your heart. You shall teach them diligently to your sons and shall talk of them when you sit in your house and when you walk on the road and when you lie down and when you rise up.” Deuteronomy 6:6–7.
Moses was instructing Israel to keep God’s commands before their children throughout daily life. This passage does not discuss Santa Claus or childhood fantasy. It does show that teaching children about God belongs in the ordinary life of the home, carried by parents who first take His words to heart themselves.
That includes the example we set. Our children learn something about the value of truth from how we speak, how we answer questions, and whether we admit when we have been wrong. We cannot control every conclusion they will reach, but we are responsible for the honesty of our teaching.
Jesus said, “I am the way, and the truth, and the life; no one comes to the Father but through Me.” John 14:6. He was speaking to His disciples about their access to the Father through Him. His claim concerns who He is and the salvation found in Him. Teaching that claim deserves care, explanation, and room for honest questions.
A child asking whether Jesus is real needs more than, “Because I told you so.” We can open Scripture together, explain what the Gospel writers recorded, and discuss why we believe their testimony. As children grow, we can help them examine harder questions. When we do not know an answer, we can say so and learn together.
Parents who have already presented imaginary characters as real do not need to become defensive. They can acknowledge what they did plainly: “We wanted you to enjoy the tradition, but we should have explained that it was pretend.” An honest admission gives children an example of taking responsibility.
The question is whether we value a child’s excitement enough to invent a convincing story, while valuing that child’s trust enough to tell the truth.
Someday, our children will examine what we taught them. Let us give them good reason to remember that when we spoke about Jesus, we took both His truth and their questions seriously.

Reader Comments
No approved comments yet.